Brother's Pizza new york style

Enjoy delicious New York-style pizza at Brother's Pizza in Altoona, PA. Under new management, offering dine-in, takeout, and delivery with fresh ingredients, affordable prices, and a family-friendly atmosphere. Open Tuesday-Saturday for lunch and dinner.

MenuContact

Welcome to Brother's Pizza new york style

Signature Dining Experience

Brother's Pizza new york style
Brother's Pizza new york style
Brother's Pizza new york style
Brother's Pizza new york style

Brother's Pizza in Altoona, PA, brings the iconic flavors of New York-style pizza to the heart of Blair County. Located at 1632 Pleasant Valley Blvd, our pizzeria offers a warm, casual environment perfect for lunch, dinner, or a quick late-night bite. Recently under new management since July 15, 2025, we focus on quality ingredients, authentic recipes, and friendly service. Whether you’re craving a classic cheese pie, a hearty steak sandwich, or a fresh salad, Brother's Pizza delivers on flavor and value. Our menu features pizzas by the slice, calzones, strombolis, wings, and Italian favorites that satisfy a variety of appetites.

We cater to families, groups, and solo diners alike, with wheelchair-accessible facilities and versatile service options including takeout, delivery, and dine-in. Come taste the difference a local, new management can make and join our community of pizza lovers.

Location & Contact

Address

1632 Pleasant Valley Blvd, Altoona, PA 16602, United States

Phone

+1 814-942-1900

About

Brother's Pizza new york style
Brother's Pizza new york style
Brother's Pizza new york style
Brother's Pizza new york style

Brother's Pizza is a beloved Italian restaurant in Altoona, Pennsylvania, now under new ownership as of July 15, 2025. Our mission focuses on blending authentic New York pizza craftsmanship with a hometown feel. We source fresh ingredients daily, from flavorful mushrooms and ripe tomatoes to quality meats, ensuring each dish exceeds expectations. Our kitchen team, led by experienced chefs, crafts every pie, stromboli, and sub with care and precision. We aim to be more than just a pizza place; we want to be a community staple where families gather, friends celebrate, and everyone feels at home.

We continually update our menu based on customer feedback—many of whom return for our signature strombolis, wings, and Italian classics. We take pride in our speed, cleanliness, and friendly service, making sure each visit leaves a memorable taste. Our goal? To keep the spirit of New York-style pizzeria alive and thriving in Altoona.

Work Hours

  • SundayClosed
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday11 AM–9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM–9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM–9 PM
  • Friday11 AM–9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM–9 PM

Brother's Pizza offers a diverse menu with a focus on authentic New York-style pizza. Our 16-inch large cheese pizza starts at just $14.99, with options for extra toppings or gluten-free crusts. We’re known for our strombolis—made to order with various fillings—plus calzones, wings, cold and heated subs, and fresh salads. Our prices keep pizza accessible, ranging from $9.99 for small cheese pies to $19.99 for the full-bodied Brother's Special stromboli.

We accept credit and debit cards, and our service options include delivery, takeaway, and sit-down dining. We’re a hub for quick bites and family meals, with kids’ menus, high chairs, and wheelchair-friendly amenities. During peak times on Fridays at 5 PM, we reach full capacity, but weekday hours from 11 AM to 1 PM are ideal for quieter visits. Our community appreciates the balance of quality, price, and welcoming atmosphere.

Brother's Pizza new york style

Brother's Pizza boasts a welcoming exterior at 1632 Pleasant Valley Blvd, with a bright signage and a wheelchair-accessible entrance that invites all. The outdoor area features a simple, family-friendly vibe—perfect for quick stops or casual gatherings. Our parking lot offers free street and lot parking, ensuring stress-free access. The atmosphere inside remains casual and lively, with a friendly staff that greets every guest warmly. Whether you're stopping by for a quick slice or settling in for a hearty meal, the community-oriented environment makes every visit feel like a neighborhood tradition.

During warmer months, our outdoor seating offers a relaxed spot to enjoy a pizza slice while chatting with friends or watching the Altoona streets bustle by, adding to our neighborhood charm.

Customer Reviews

We haven't had brothers in years bc it just went down hill. We seen there was new owners and gave it a try. We got a large meat stromboli, a calzone, and a large salad. The boli and calzone was cooked perfectly and I liked the new style. Our poor delivery driver was soaked from the rain.We will def be back.

B
Betty W.

Did they fire the other cook Stromboli not the same? That person has no clue how a Stromboli is made very disappointed!!! Guess ill find another place bought from brothers since hills and riverside was at the station mall.

M
Martin H.

This place is just Amazing! The pizza, the Fried food and even the environment! Cheap prices for the pizza! Good Job Brothers Pizza now only if we can have you open 24/7 😆

E
Emilee

New owners as of 7/15/2025. I’m a new customer here and will stay thst way. Came in on opening day and got a couple of strombolis. The strombolis were good but the marinara dipping sauce was soooooo good. New owner was friendly and had a family vibe to the place. Will be back the next time I’m craving a Stromboli

B
Barry C.

Continues to be the best pizza in Altoona. New owners seem to have kept the best parts. Service was very polite and on time.

C
Colin S.

I just ordered some food from this place via doordash and TBH I was nervous because normally when I try a new place it's not good..Needless to say I was pleasantly surprised..Everything was delicious...10 out of 10 .I would definitely recommend..❤️

R
Robin W.